It’s taken 12 years or so for Tom Kitt & Brian Yorkey’s musical to get onto a London stage, even though it’s been produced in 20 other countries in between in Asia, Australasia, South & Central America and 11 in Europe. We’ve had four other Tom Kitt shows in fringe venues since, three composed after Next to Normal. Anyway, we now get the chance to see it at last in the intimate setting of the Donmar, and it was well worth waiting for.
Diana & Dan got married whilst still at university when Diana became pregnant. Their son Gabe didn’t survive his 1st birthday and her mental health has suffered for most of the seventeen years or so since. She’s been diagnosed bi-polar which has been treated with psychotherapy, many different drugs and finally ECT. Her husband Dan has supported her throughout. She is still grieving the loss of her son Gabe who appears to her constantly, and has never really bonded with her second child Natalie. Mental health is a rare subject for musical theatre (only Dear Evan Hansen comes to mind, but that was some time later) but here I think it proves illuminating and insightful and is handled sensitively.
A common criticism of chamber musicals like this (well, by me!) is that they lack originality, being too formulaic and too Sondheimesque (no offence, I’m a big fan!) but this is an exception; one of the best new scores I’ve heard for some time, so much so I downloaded it as soon as I got home. Its musical styles vary depending on the scene, from rock to ballad, always inventive. It’s beautifully sung, particularly by Caissie Levy as Diana, who has a gorgeous voice. Michael Longhurst’s staging is just as inventive, with Chloe Lamford’s two-tier set allowing action on the upper tier, where the band are on view when Tal Rosner’s projections aren’t, and on the stairs between the two.
It’s hard to imagine a more committed, passionate set of performances that are equally good in both acting and singing. Caissie Levy & Jamie Parker are outstanding as Diana & Dan, deeply emotional performances which you could hear in their voices. The three younger actors – Eleanor Worthington-Cox as Natalie, Jack Wolfe as her dead brother Gabe and Jack Ofrecio as her boyfriend Henry – are all terrific. Trevor Dion Nicholas is great playing all of the doctors who treat Diana.
I loved this show and if it wasn’t sold out already I’d return to see it again.